scartol's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[K.]

Sigh

THIS is what gets 3.5 while my work languishes at 2.9?

Woe betide upon Newgrounds..

KnottsberryClock responds:

Don't scorn me just because your work isn't up to standard :-)

[Consumed]

Nice postloader

Overall, this is kind of thin and insubstantial. I like the overall feel of it, but it's pretty unpolished. The sound cut off in the middle (maybe it's my setup). I really like the post-viewing interface..

Zima-The-Impaler responds:

there was no sound cut off in the real version, afraid thats on your end. Maybe your machine was fighting against the truth ;)

[Nuclear Warfare N. Korea]

You obviously put some work into this, BUT..

It just feels thin and insubstantial. I agree with the anti-Iraq-war message, but why focus on North Korea? Israel has much more recently said that it will use its nukes if Iraq attacks it. (And why would Iraq attack Israel? If it feels threatened by the US.)

Funny how much Beijing looks like Tokyo. =)

Kurt Vonnegut recently wrote a letter to the New York Times (which they chose not to publish). This is the entire letter:

"In the history of the world, only one country has ever had the audacity to use an atomic weapon."

James-Ball responds:

North Korea is part of the "Axis of Evil" and said that if the us attacks it will attack japan s kore or china and they do have the bomb its more that a 3 fewel

[{The Dance}]

This has potential

I like the graphic, but the movie doesn't really have a point, nor does it make me smile. The style is fluid, but I was pretty bored after a while.

Keep at it!

RLL-BABY responds:

it made me smile.

[8) Nothing makes Sense]

Yes, potential

I like your characters' style, especially the big heads and the 3/4 perspectives.

But it looks like you didn't really have an idea for a story, you just wanted to make a movie. Unfortunately, there's not enough here for me to sink my teeth into.

Keep at it, tho!

sebisthecoolest responds:

3/4 perpsective? huh? oh well... the art is just easy to draw so i do it